The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
 
News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In

Some of people at the GA were opposed to restricting anyone from Occupy Boston based on the state's sex-offender standards.

Even Barney said she can agree with these concerns, to an extent.

"I do understand where they're coming from," she said. "I don't think the American justice system or the police departments work effectively, and a lot of people get through the cracks. If you're a certain race or economic status, you get away with a lot more. That's one of the reasons I'm at Occupy Boston."

That's why Barney limited the proposal to level-three sex offenders. "It's pretty hard to be labeled 'level three' unless you've gone someplace pretty dark, pretty violent, pretty bad," she said.

On January 8, the proposal was brought up, and blocked. At Occupy, there's a complex procedure for how a proposal can be blocked; it takes a three-quarters vote on whether the block is a valid, or "principled," block, before participants vote for or against the proposal; in the end, it takes only the votes of 10 percent of those present to cement the block. On the night in question, that required only eight people.

One of the eight was a man named Paul Shannon. Shannon did not reveal his affiliations at the time, but was later identified as a key proponent of an organization called "Reform Sex Offender Laws." The reason that's important is that Occupy's "statement of autonomy" requires participants to disclose any outside organizations they represent. It's essentially Occupy's conflict-of-interest statement.

"Any organization is welcome to support us," reads the statement. "We acknowledge the existence of professional activists who work to make our world a better place. If you are representing, or being compensated by an independent source in order to participate in our process, please disclose your affiliation at the outset."

In an e-mail to an Occupy Boston listserv, Shannon wrote, "Since I was only allowed to comment from the audience the other night I did not think I would be allowed to mention various positions I have, as no one else in the audience did. But I would have wanted to speak of the dozens of mothers, wives, and girlfriends who call me from around the country talking about how their lives and the lives of their children have been ruined by the fact that their son or husband has been unfairly classified on sex-offender registries. But that seemed beside the point."

Whether or not Shannon had disclosed his affiliation, Occupy Boston's system of direct democracy means that even a person who had rarely attended Occupy events in the past could come to an assembly and "kidnap it," as Women's Caucus member Ren Jender described it to me the next evening.

"The community doesn't have a good way for dealing, through the process, with blocks of that nature," said Ross. "Is it really consensus if eight or nine people can thwart what seemed like the strong will of the whole of Occupy Boston? No, I don't think so.

"[It's] the culture of misogyny that prevails in our society at large," she added. "Like it or not, we're a microcosm of that society."

< prev  1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |   next >
Related: After the occupation, Occupy First Night, Occupy, more occupy, even more occupy, More more >
  Topics: News Features , feminism, News, Occupy Boston,  More more >
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 01/22 ]   Daniel McCuster Dance Projects: ThIStHaT ShoW no.4 AND no.5.  @ Central Square Theater
[ 01/22 ]   Zoé Dance and Expandance  @ Oberon
[ 01/22 ]   ":: MISLED*YOUTH ::"  @ Fourth Wall Project
ARTICLES BY LIZ PELLY
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   AS OCCUPY BOSTON STRUGGLES WITH A SEX-OFFENDER BAN, ITS WEAKNESSES HAVE BEEN LAID BARE  |  January 18, 2012
    It was after 10 pm on Tuesday, January 10, in the stale, bright basement of the Arlington Street Church, where now-nomadic Occupy Boston was holding a meeting.
  •   OUT: PIECING TOGETHER NEW YEAR’S EVE AT O’BRIEN’S PUB  |  January 04, 2012
    Allston never felt more promwave than Saturday night at O'Brien's Pub, as the Earthquake Party, Fagettes, and the New Highway Hymnal rang in 2012 on a stage set with twinkling lights, prismacolor streamers, and a homemade "Age of Aquarius" banner.
  •   INDIE LABELS FILL THE MAJORS' VOID IN 2011  |  December 20, 2011
    During a year when political conversations are increasingly focused on the widening gap between the rich and poor, the corporate elite versus the rest of the world, it makes sense that arts criticism follow.
  •   NAME THAT NON-LETHAL WEAPON  |  December 14, 2011
    When Boston Police stormed Dewey Square last week in an early morning raid, arresting protesters and destroying the last of Occupy Boston's tent city, they brought with them a frightening, seldom-used weapon.
  •   REVIEW: FROM THE BACK OF THE ROOM  |  December 06, 2011
    Chronicling the past 30 years of women in DIY punk, Amy Oden's documentary deconstructs the myth that punk is an ideal world free of gender prejudices.

 See all articles by: LIZ PELLY

MOST POPULAR
RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed