The Phoenix Network:
 
 
About  |  Advertise
 
News Features  |  Talking Politics  |  This Just In
Best2012Vote-1000x50

Devils in the details

John McCain or Mitt Romney: Hard to say who’s worse
By EDITORIAL  |  November 22, 2006

061124_mccain_main
Arizona senator John McCain appears to be the nation’s most popular Republican. That, at least, is what most polls show. It’s not entirely clear why. He has authored little noteworthy legislation during his 20 years in the Senate and, in fact, has accomplished almost nothing beyond co-sponsoring the McCain-Feingold Act — campaign-finance legislation that has failed to stem the influence of money in politics.

Not that he cares. McCain took up the cause of campaign finance only to salvage his reputation and political career, after getting caught as one of the “Keating 5,” who pressured federal agents to drop their investigation into one of their biggest campaign financiers.

McCain is not only cynical and opportunistic, he’s a hypocrite: when asked this past Sunday by George Stephanopoulos whether he intends to opt out of his own campaign restrictions, as John Kerry did in 2004, McCain would not rule it out.

McCain specializes in seizing on, and grandstanding about, feel-good issues like campaign-finance reform. He decries torture, steroid use in baseball, and Internet porn.

On tougher issues, he bends to whatever his political needs might be at any given moment. Currently seeking the Republican nomination, he is tacking hard to the right. He once defended Roe v. Wade; now he staunchly favors overturning it. Last year he stopped the Senate Republicans from deploying the “nuclear option” to confirm reactionary judges; last week he spoke to the conservative Federalist Society about the importance of appointing and confirming ideologically pure “originalists.” He voted against the Bush tax cuts in 2001 and 2003; this year he voted to make them permanent.

But his most cynical, and dangerous, campaign ploy is his insistence that the US must send more troops to Iraq.

As with his shameless embrace of campaign-finance reform after getting caught out on the issue, McCain has taken his most recent position on Iraq to salvage his reputation — now that his longstanding Iraq-war boosterism has turned into a political liability. By calling for more troops — which he knows will never happen — McCain will be able to claim that he could have averted whatever horrible events are in store for Iraq in the future.

Of course, to flog this policy he must, as he did on Sunday, agree in principle to sending already over-used troops back for third and fourth tours in the killing zone.

How can a former prisoner of war do this to US soldiers? Well, how could he tacitly approve of the Swift Boat slander of his friend John Kerry’s heroic military service? How could he bite his tongue at the convention where Republican delegates wore purple Band-Aids to mock Kerry’s Purple Heart?

John McCain has proven he is capable of doing anything if it serves his own political interest. He almost got America to buy his act in 2000; voters should be warier this time around.

Conservatives who aren’t buying McCain’s newfound embrace of their issues are looking at Mitt Romney as a possible alternative for the Republican nomination, as David S. Bernstein reports. All they will find is a politician who is just as opportunistic, self-serving, and hypocritical as McCain.

1  |  2  |   next >
Related: Can Mitt win?, Diagnostic politics, Presidential toteboard: To run, or not to run, More more >
  Topics: The Editorial Page , Mitt Romney, Election Campaigns, Elections and Voting,  More more >
| More

 Friends' Activity   Popular   Most Viewed 
[ 02/02 ]   Adam Johnson  @ Porter Square Books
[ 02/02 ]   "Brewers Helping Neighbors 2012"  @ Harriet Tubman House
[ 02/02 ]   Jason Moran  @ Jordan Hall
ARTICLES BY EDITORIAL
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   OBAMA'S VISION: ''AN AMERICA BUILT TO LAST''  |  January 25, 2012
    By any measure, President Barack Obama's State of the Union speech would have been considered a political winner, but coming just one day after the Republicans' constipated Florida-primary debate, Obama scored an undeniable triumph.
  •   STOPPING SOPA  |  January 18, 2012
    You can almost breathe a sigh of relief, though the fight is long from over. As of this writing, it looks increasingly as if Congress will — miraculously — fail to break the Internet.
  •   ROMNEY'S SECRET FORMULA  |  January 12, 2012
    The Republican nomination thing may not be as complicated as the media is making it out to be, but it sure is fun.
  •   HOW 'THREE STRIKES' LEGISLATION FAILS  |  January 04, 2012
    Despite evidence that "three strikes" mandatory sentencing laws don't work, are punishingly expensive for taxpayers, and make an already unfair criminal-justice system even more irrational and racist, the Massachusetts legislature seems hell-bent on enacting one.
  •   BOENHER'S SHAME: THE PUTRID POLITICS OF REPUBLICAN NEGATIVITY.  |  December 21, 2011
    Pity John Boehner. By rights, as Speaker of the House of Representatives, Boehner should be considered one of Washington's most powerful leaders.

 See all articles by: EDITORIAL

MOST POPULAR
RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed