June 27 - July 4, 1 9 9 6
Check out the Don't Quote Me archive.
Other hot sites
It's empowering, in a way, for people to be able to use the Web to satisfy
their need for self-expression by showing off snapshots of their cats,
expounding on their views of the universe, or sharing photos of themselves in
the throes of orgasm.
And because the Web is a cheap publishing medium available around the world,
24/7, it has quickly established itself as the perfect repository for
specialized information on subjects ranging from Finland to physics, from Dylan
to dwarfism.
But if you're looking for quality, general-interest content, you're going to
come up with a mighty short list of sites. The following is a guide to the best
of the webzines on serious political, social, and cultural topics.
HotWired
>Perhaps the first high-profile, commercial webzine (it debuted
in late 1994), HotWired continues to reinvent itself with new looks and
new passions. Despite close ties with its parent magazine, Wired, what
you'll find here is entirely original. HotWired is both wide and deep.
My favorite stops include Netizen, a political 'zine-within-a-'zine;
"Net Surf," a daily guide to the best (and weirdest) of the Web; "Flux," a
bitchy gossip column by Ned Brainard, who's devoted his life to making America
Online honcho (and "former soap salesman") Steve Case miserable; and
"Muckraker," by technolibertarian Brock Meeks.
Downsides include an oversupply of attitude (made worse by the sophomoric use
of the F-word) and a slow, complex new interface that not only divides your
screen into frames, but actually opens a second browser window filled with
cryptic navigation tools.
Location: http://www.hotwired.com.
Urban Desires
Very hip, with a fast, elegant interface, Urban
Desires fancies itself as "an interactive magazine of metropolitan
passions." Here you'll find very short fiction, book reviews, photography, art,
music, food, travel, movies, and talk. You'll also find "The Rant," an aptly
titled exercise in scatology, formatted like a ransom note, that includes a
sound clip of someone with a Texas twang yelling, "Shut the fuck up,
asswipe!"
Urban Desires is also a favorite destination of cybernauts who want a
little sex but who don't necessarily want to look at the photos in, say,
alt.binaries.pictures.erotica.bestiality.
The current issue features
"Untrue to You: 12 Conversations About Cheating," Q&As with the likes of
Nicholson Baker, Katie Roiphe, and Xaviera "The Happy Hooker" Hollander.
Location: http://desires.com.
Salon
Started last fall by refugees from Hearst's almost-dead San
Francisco Examiner, this is far more like a traditional magazine than most
web-zines. With a fast, simple interface, Salon emphasizes good writing
by big names, such as social critics Camille Paglia and Todd Gitlin. The
orientation is toward arts and culture, although there's a fair amount of news
and media criticism, too, especially in the two-month-old "Daily Clicks"
section. (Full disclosure: I write an every-other-week column for
Salon's "Media Circus.")
What's missing, with rare exceptions, is real journalism: feature stories
heavy on research and interviews. Taken one at a time, the essays on
Salon are quite good; together, their self-indulgence grates. A recent
piece by Jerusalem Report's Washington correspondent Jonathan Broder on
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's American supporters was a welcome
departure. Perhaps Slate will push Salon to do more.
Location: http://www.salon1999.com.
Suck
With its non sequitur slogan of "a fish, a barrel, and a smoking
gun," Suck has built a reputation as one of the hippest reads on the
Net. Suck's m.o. is to publish a daily rant trashing some corner of
cyberspace that it considers insufficiently cool. But its promise of
"provocation, mordant deconstruction, and buzz-saw journalism" is often more
than it can live up to.
Suck's original, samizdat-style appeal -- text-only screeds
presented in the ugly Courier typeface -- has been supplanted by a
slow-loading, slick new design. Moreover, the Sucksters sold out to
HotWired only a few months after going on-line. Worth a look, but
Suck's 15 minutes may be just about up.
Location: http://www.suck.com.
Word
At one time Word's interface was spare and elegant. Now
it's maddening, with frames, distracting animation, confusing screen switches
that leave you unsure of where you are and where you should go, and a painfully
slow interface.
Which is too bad, because there's some good stuff here, such as "Can't Sleep,"
a photo essay by Cambridge's Karl Baden; an excerpt from David Foster Wallace's
novel Infinite Jest, as well as the transcript of an on-line interview
with him; a story by Devon Jackson on the coming collapse of Social Security;
and a lengthy, quite moving first-person account of the malling of Auschwitz by
David Lazarus.
Location:http://www.word.com.
Feed
In contrast to Word, you'll find a clean layout, an
easy-to-navigate interface, and attractive, retro art. The current opening
illustration is a hoot: two men in suits and a nude woman, with laptops and
cell phones, relaxing by the riverside, while another woman in a white robe
bends over the water. Huh?
Editor-in-chief Steven Johnson has the right idea, writing that "the
current frenzy to re-invent journalism from scratch looks like a dangerous mix
of unchecked hubris and cultural amnesia." Execution, though, is uneven. A
piece titled "Sympathy for the Unabomber?", by technology critic Mark Slouka,
is excellent; but an essay by Mary Granfield, "The Molester Within," is a
remarkably shallow look at a complex topic, as she accepts almost without
question the notion that most accused perpetrators are innocent. An effort to
annotate Bill Gates's wretched The Road from Here should be funny;
instead, it's turgid and pedantic.
Location: http://www.feedmag.co.
Firefly
A hot, mostly rock-and-roll site based in Cambridge,
Firefly uses interactive technology developed at the MIT Media Lab to
create something that feels more like a community than a webzine. It features
music, movies, reviews (read them, or write your own), sound clips, talk,
on-line live performances, and record reviews from Rolling Stone.
Firefly requires users to register, but that allows for the possibility
of personalized content. This is on the cutting edge of new media, and is as
different from Slate and Salon as Ray Gun is from the
Partisan Review.
Location: http://www.firefly.com.
Intellectual Capital
A shockingly high-quality new webzine published by
former Delaware governor Pierre "Call Me Pete" DuPont, an ultraconservative
Republican who once ran for president. Intellectual Capital features
commentaries by conservatives such as Russia expert Richard Pipes and
Washington Post columnist James Glassman, and policy debates between
right-wingers such as Family Research Council president Gary Bauer and
centrists such as National Urban League president Hugh Price.
With a simple, easy interface, DuPont has come up with a winner. Let's hope
some enterprising lefty takes note, so we can be treated to debates between
Noam Chomsky and Molly Ivins.
Location:
http://www.intellectual capital.com.
Spiv and Stim
Long on sensibility, short on information.
Spiv manages to bring massive attitude to bear on China's oppression of
Tibet. The hip factor seems more forced at Stim, which may have
something to do with the identity of its owner, the extremely unhip Prodigy
on-line service. Both are worth a look, but caveat surfer.
Locations: http://www.spiv.com and
http://www.stim.com.
-- Dan Kennedy