Un air de famille
If happy families are all alike, then movies based on plays about unhappy
families tend to be the same in their formulaic staginess. Cédric
Klapisch's adaptation of a theaterpiece by Agnès Jaoui and Jean-Pierre
Bacri (who also star) struggles to free itself from its origins, and it does
manage some moments of poignance and absurdity, not to mention those little
shocks of recognition that anyone with parents and siblings will register.
The occasion here is a family birthday get-together set in "Sleepy Dad's
Café," a threadbare small-town bistro run by Henri (an anal and
affecting Bacri). He's the less favored of two brothers; Philippe (an anal and
unappealing Wladimir Yordanoff) is a successful and insufferable businessman
who's just appeared on the TV news. The celebrant is Philippe's meek,
long-suffering wife, Yolande (Catherine Frot); in attendance are the boys'
shrewish mother (Claire Maurier) and their loose-cannon, over-30-and-unmarried
sister Betty (Jaoui). Serving as objective point-of-view -- and sly erotic
interest -- is Henri's mellow counterman Denis (Jean-Pierre Darroussin), whose
insights into the clan's pathology are largely ignored, though a glint of
liberation shines in the end.
Less than liberated is Klapisch himself. He shows inventiveness in his use of
the single set (à la Robert Altman's Come Back to the Five & Dime
Jimmy Dean) and in his periodic flashbacks to younger but not necessarily
more innocent days. Yet the shadow of the proscenium makes one long for the
serendipity of his previous effort, When the Cat's Away.
-- Peter Keough