In a Newport defeat, lessons for the 99%

The Public Square
By BRIAN C. JONES  |  December 29, 2011

BATTLEGROUND The approved proposal.

The Battle of Queen Anne Square ended in a terrible rout for opponents of a private foundation's plan to renovate a charming, tiny park in downtown Newport.

After six months of a vigorous, emotional campaign to scuttle the project, they lost an overwhelming 5 to 1 vote by the Newport City Council, with one member absent. So unafraid of the critics were some council members that they scolded the losers for "maligning" the project's designer, renowned artist Maya Lin, and insulting the council's integrity.

Still, the humiliating December 14 loss may have tactical lessons for other populist uprisings, namely the Occupy movements, which, decamping from parks in Providence and across the nation, are plotting their next moves.

The Newport protest shared some characteristics of the Occupy movements: a spontaneous, idealistic, grassroots rebellion against powerful, private interests.

What could opponents have done differently?

Certainly, they employed the usual tools, speaking at hearings, flooding newspapers with letters, running a comprehensive Web site and attracting national attention, including a report in The New York Times.

Laurence S. Cutler, founder of the National Museum of American Illustration in Newport, and part of the loose confederation of critics, noted his steps:

He buttonholed supporters, including Marion Oates Charles, the president of the Newport Restoration Foundation, which had proposed the park makeover with $3.5 million in private funds, and hired Lin, designer of Washington's Vietnam memorial. Cutler lobbied City Council members. He invited a national expert, Paul D. Spreiregen, to Newport to review the design, and then publicized Spreiregen's devastating assessment of Lin's plan.

"I think we did everything we could have done," Cutler told the Phoenix, saying the council majority seemed oblivious to arguments that changes to a public park needed a public process, such as a competition inviting alternative designs.

"What happened, at least in Newport, and maybe nationally," Cutler said, "is that democracy died a little here."

But Justin S. McLaughlin, a council member who voted for the project, said opponents might also have concentrated on the simple math of local politics.

A former naval defense analyst, McLaughlin said that if an issue is up to a seven-member council, "you must get four votes, no matter what."

The council sensed that the opposition consisted of 20 to 30 people, McLaughlin said. While he heard from and spoke with many in the core group, he said he was contacted by only five other constituents, out of a potential 4500.

He did read opponents' letters to the newspapers, but McLaughlin would have been more impressed if critics had persuaded 100 voters to tell him that they also opposed the plan.

Even that might not have worked. McLaughlin prides himself on judging the merits of an issue.

But the lesson of Queen Anne Square seems as obvious as it is difficult to accomplish: for an underdog, grassroots movement to succeed, it has to do it the old-fashioned way — door-to-door, one person at a time, until the votes add up.

Related: Obama responds to the 99 percent, 99% vs. 1% — on the left, The Place, More more >
  Topics: This Just In , Newport, Occupy, 99 percent
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   ON VALENTINE'S DAY, A TOAST TO A MAN WRONGED  |  February 15, 2012
    They raised a toast this Valentine's Day at McBride's Pub in Providence to John Gordon, much-remembered these past 167 years.
  •   IN A NEWPORT DEFEAT, LESSONS FOR THE 99%  |  December 29, 2011
    The Battle of Queen Anne Square ended in a terrible rout for opponents of a private foundation's plan to renovate a charming, tiny park in downtown Newport.
    Newport's Queen Anne Square, which measures just over an acre, is a rectangle of grass and trees on the doorstep of historic Trinity Episcopal Church, overlooking the city's yacht-filled harbor. Crisscrossed by brick pathways, it reminds many of a college or village green.
  •   TAKING THE FOOD STAMP CHALLENGE  |  November 02, 2011
    My breakfast on Day One of "The Food Stamp Challenge" cost 81 cents.
  •   WHY CARE FOR ME, BUT NOT POOR RI KIDS?  |  May 08, 2008
    On weekdays this spring, I’ve been driving from my home in Newport to Rhode Island Hospital in Providence, where I lie under a fabulous machine that’s saving my life.

 See all articles by: BRIAN C. JONES