Like many thoughtful voters, I have privately wondered what would happen if John McCain, Hillary Clinton, or Barack Obama were to die after being nominated. The question, in this unusual election, is often pushed aside, but reality gnaws at it.
Today’s potential nominees seem at greater risk than usual. McCain’s age and his silence about his health raise concerns. Clinton generates angry reactions from the significant numbers of those who consistently tell pollsters that they “hate” her. Obama forces America’s unresolved racial bigotry into the light, adding volume to whispered epithets against those still called the “N” word by too many.
Obama’s perceived vulnerability gets the most attention, but a search of the Internet reveals a torrent of queries from those evaluating McCain’s life expectancy. Speculation that a Hillary-hater might try to harm her is verbalized least, but the Secret Service agents assigned to her probably understand that possibility.
CNN’s Larry King asked Michelle Obama if she worried that “terrible things could happen?” Her perfect answer was, “Of course [terrible things could happen], but so could wonderful things.”
In response to concerns about his age, McCain introduces his hearty mother, closing in on 96. If he has her genes, goes the implication, he’s good for two terms.
Assassination speculation, of course, hides behind the media’s uncharacteristic desire not to appear tasteless and the public’s fear that confronting such a possibility might push a wacko into action. Given America’s history, however, this prospect cannot be trivialized.
Many believe the Constitution has the answer if a nominee who is not yet elected or sworn-in dies before taking office. The 20th Amendment, however, only addresses the succession of those already elected.
In his book, After the People Vote: A Guide to the Electoral College (AEI Press, 2004), John C. Fortier, who has taught at Harvard, Boston College and the University of Pennsylvania, writes that a presidential or vice-presidential nominee who dies before Election Day in November, is replaced by the national committee of that candidate’s party. Such committees also select the replacement if a candidate were to die or resign after the November elections, but before January 6, when the Electoral College votes.
If a candidate elected in November dies between January 6 and the January 20 swearing-in, the constitutional line of succession applies.
In 1972, when vice-presidential candidate Thomas Eagleton resigned from the Democratic ticket topped by George McGovern, the DNC chose R. Sargent Shriver. In 1968, the Democratic convention hastily coroneted Hubert Humphrey when Robert Kennedy, the assumed standard-bearer, was killed.
Now, neither Clinton nor Obama can amass enough primary delegates to go to the convention in Denver as the nominee-apparent. Superdelegates are widely cited as the “deciders” regarding this year’s ticket. No other scenarios, however dark they may seem, are broadly discussed.
DNC chair Howard Dean’s influence on the democratic (and Democratic) processes may be tremendously underrated, as may be that of RNC chair Robert M. Duncan. At least the forefathers (“in their wisdom”) won’t be blamed — or credited — with the outcome should America face a president chosen by committee.
Related:
What Obama must do, Obamastrology, Rallying cries, More 
- What Obama must do
For all the fawning press Barack Obama has received, the grace and favor with which he has been treated is nothing compared with the free ride McCain has enjoyed.
- Obamastrology
Another Leo president. That's what we're getting with Barack Obama, and it's even good news on an astrological level.
- Rallying cries
Though the press focuses on organization, tactics, and fundraising, campaigns are won by unifying ideas.
- The battle of the smallest state
Clinton bathed in the intense affection of an adoring crowd, her every statement punctuated by wild applause, chants, and a rising sea of blue signs touting her campaign.
- Night of the living dead
It’s almost over. This is welcome news.
- Granite up for grabs
Presidential candidates and their surrogates spend most of their time in high-population, close-contest areas.
- Let the horse race begin
Welcome to the 2008 Presidential Tote Board.
- Profile polling
Facebook and MySpace represent the easiest and most efficient method of assessing compatibility for a friend, a potential hook-up, or a presidential candidate.
- 2009: Rants of the Right
Few "respectable" publications were willing to review the year's top-selling conservative books, but the Phoenix has no fear. After wading through 2500 or so pages of right-wing ravings, your brave correspondent reports back with the following analyses.
- EXCLUSIVE: California gleaming
According to a poll obtained exclusively by the Boston Phoenix , Hillary Clinton leads Barack Obama by 11 percentage points in California.
- Will bigotry doom Obama
It wasn’t so long ago when women had little chance of stepping outside the kitchen to make real differences in the public and private sector.
- Less
Topics:
This Just In
, Barack Obama, Elections and Voting, Politics, More
, Barack Obama, Elections and Voting, Politics, U.S. Politics, U.S. Presidential Election, Robert F. Kennedy, John McCain, U.S. Secret Service, Michelle Obama, Democratic National Committee, Less
