Muddled histories

ASP's Henry IV, Part I
By STEVE VINEBERG  |  October 12, 2010

CONCEPT CRISIS: Trying to insert the “facts” of Richard II into Henry IV doesn’t work.

The work of Actors' Shakespeare Project is generally smart and imaginative, so the company's thoroughly misbegotten Henry IV, Part I, the first half of ASP's The Coveted Crown (at Midway Studios through November 21), comes as a surprise. Patrick Swanson's production begins with what the program calls a prologue from Richard II that parallels Bolingbroke's usurpation of Richard's crown (an act that turns him into King Henry IV) with Worcester's rebellion toward the end of Henry's reign — a rebellion that Henry's army, with prodigal son Hal at its head, spends at least half of the two parts of Henry IV putting down. The problem is that the prologue runs nearly half an hour and includes extracts from four separate scenes from Richard II. That's overkill — and a challenge ASP isn't prepared to meet. The Richard interpolations are wobbly and unconvincing, and Marya Lowry, cross-gender-cast as the doomed king, is so lost in the role that she seems to be swimming in it. She's better as Worcester, though Swanson's idea to cast the same actor in both roles to suggest that the ghost of Henry's past is coming back to haunt him works only if you don't think too hard about how Shakespeare presents Henry — as a chastened Christian ruler converted by Richard's fate.

Henry IV, Part I is such a marvelous coming-of-age play that it usually works on some level, but this version has been miscast almost straight down the line. Bill Barclay's Hal lacks charm and in his early scenes seems almost sinister; his reading of the great soliloquy that ends "I'll so offend to make offense a skill/Redeeming time when men think least I will" is closer in tone to Edmund's rejoicing in his own villainy in Lear than to the promise of a dissolute young prince to show his noble colors at last. Allyn Burrows, ASP's artistic director, is a good decade and a half too old to pull off the prince's opposite number, Hotspur, whom his uncle Worcester's rebellion, if it succeeds, will put on the throne in place of Hal. Burrows was first-rate as Timon of Athens last season, but here he seems perversely wrong. So do Sarah Newhouse as his wife, Lady Percy (they might have stepped out of a 1950s sit-com), and Bobbie Steinbach, ludicrously costumed, as the innkeeper Mistress Quickly. (The program lists no designers, which is unfortunate, because the best thing about the show is the lighting.)

As Falstaff, the companion of the prince's misspent youth, Robert Walsh gets his laughs, but his merriness feels put on, like his fat suit: he doesn't move like a man of Falstaff's bulk. In the play's scheme, he and the king are foils just as Hal and Hotspur are — they're Hal's two fathers, one for holidays, one for every day. Joel Colodner fares better than most of the ensemble as Henry, but whereas Burrows is too old for Hotspur, Colodner is too young. Here, though, the trouble isn't miscasting. By introducing Henry as the Bolingbroke of Richard II, Swanson has no choice but to cast an actor whom we can believe as a warrior rebel, strong enough to seize Richard's throne. But when he moves from Richard II to Henry IV, Shakespeare ages Henry. It's theatrical sleight of hand: in a brand-new play, we don't mind that the 40ish king who complains of his "unthrifty son" has become a 60ish king who dies at the end of Part II not in battle but of old age. You can't just impose a concept on Henry IV; you have to think it through.

Related: Planting seeds, Moral surgery, Classic drama, More more >
  Topics: Theater , Theater, Patrick Swanson, Allyn Burrows,  More more >
| More

Most Popular
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   BAFFLED IN BOISE  |  October 09, 2012
    Samuel D. Hunter's A Bright New Boise, receiving its Boston premiere in a production by the Zeitgeist Stage Company, has no dramatic structure.
  •   SAD BOY  |  October 02, 2012
    The Irish playwright Brendan Behan, known for his plays The Hostage and The Quare Fellow and for his memoir Borstal Boy, was a raucous, charismatic, hard-drinking Irish Republican who began to write after he got out of prison for shooting at English detectives during a public event.
  •   GOOD PEOPLE COULD BE BETTER  |  September 24, 2012
    Good People , which opens the SEASON at the Huntington Theatre Company, is a schizoid experience.
  •   CAR TALK IS NO MUSICAL  |  June 26, 2012
    The notion of a musical inspired by Car Talk is bizarre.
  •   COWARD'S 'PRIVATE LIVES' ROARS AGAIN  |  June 05, 2012
    It wouldn't be a stretch to call Noël Coward's 1930 Private Lives the funniest play of the 20th century.

 See all articles by: STEVE VINEBERG