All in Live Reviews

All Live Reviews

Live Reviews

Bruce Springsteen and the Seeger Session Band

Well, chalk one up to the sports guys: their dismissal of Springsteen’s Seeger Sessions may not have been accurate – if We Shall Overcome is old folks’ music then so is most of Dylan’s songbook. But, sadly it was on the mark. It wasn’t so much that the crowd who flocked to the Tweeter Center on Saturday night was elderly, although it did skew older than your average Springsteen crowd, even the one that packed the Orpheum for his Devils & Dust solo tour sans E Street Band aid. That show had been transcendent and not nearly as heavy and grave as some had worried. No, Bruce was loose, almost playful, as he rapped with the crowd about everything from the genesis of certain songs too the array of odd vintage keyboards that littered the stage, including one he’d recently purchased on eBay. To say he set the bar rather high that evening would be an understatement, and may account for what made the Seeger Sessions show such a let down. (In the interest of full disclosure, I was among the few critics who only reluctantly jumped the We Shall Overcome bandwagon, mainly as I grew to appreciate the fun Springsteen brings to material too often treated with stifling reverence, and because I do believe there’s a wily political subtext to recording an album of songs by the author of "We Shall Overcome" nearly half a century after it helped spark a wave of anti-Viet Nam protest music.)

Springsteen was clearly aiming for something loose and playful this time around too. He’d had the seats removed from a large area in front of the stage – what some may have recognized as the mosh pit – in the hopes of, I dunno, a spontaneous square dance breaking out. Meanwhile, the stage was outfitted with several hanging chandeliers that gave it the feel of a fancy ballroom and, very unfortunately, brought to mind the folk-music spoof A Mighty Wind. So when out of the blue he asked the folks up front if they were "ready for a picnic?" after racing through "John Henry" it wasn’t entirely clear what he meant. Hootenanny or hoedown seemed more in line with what Bruce, his longtime harmonizer Patty Scalfia, and a busy band of 16-or-so backing musicians (they switched instruments so often that they were never standing still long enough for me to get an accurate count) had in mind, with all the banjo soloing, lap steel sliding, accordion pumping, ragtime piano pounding, and acoustic guitar strumming. But I just couldn’t get A Mighty Wind out of my mind as I watched the ragtag crew of musical ringers (including a four-man horn section) smile their way through storytelling songs from Seeger’s songbook, each of which began with a quick story about the story by a gracious Springsteen. Too gracious, I thought. He was in trying-too-hard-to-be-Bruce – the Broooose of legend – mode, singing each clenched syllable as if it might be his last, strumming his guitar like he was working an old, rusted waterpump, and smiling so hard it looked like it hurt.