Congress's war on toys

A new US law threatens to handcuff local indie artisans — and could render certain kids' products contraband
By LISSA HARRIS  |  February 9, 2009

090206_warontoys-main

Previously: Congress bans kids from libraries? By Lissa Harris.
Incredible, but true: until this past Friday, America was on a fast track to outlaw grandmothers selling children's sweaters for charity.

For now, Grandma has dodged a bullet. On February 10, makers of children's products faced onerous new regulations that would have criminalized a thriving cottage industry of handmade crafters, and threatened a vast section of the economy already gripped by a deep recession. They have won a temporary respite, but still face an uphill battle to reform the law.

This past August — spurred on by very real concerns about the safety of imported toys from places like China, where regulation is distressingly lax — Congress voted overwhelmingly to pass the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA). But did they go too far? As a result of the new law, all children's products — yes, all, from picture books to pants — will be considered dangerous until proven otherwise.

Imagine that Congress had decided to fight drunk driving by setting up permanent ID checkpoints on every road in America, and you might begin to understand the frustration of those who make or sell anything for children these days. Children's businesses, both large and small, have been calling February 10 "National Bankruptcy Day." On that date, according to the CPSIA, the total lead content of any children's product must fall below 600 parts per million. The lead limits will then be tightened again: in August, to 300 ppm, and in 2011, to 100 ppm. The law also bans phthalates, a family of plastic-softening chemicals that have been linked to reproductive health problems.

Lead is highly toxic, especially to children, and the new levels seem reasonable for toys that young children might chew on. (The EPA considers soil with more than 400 ppm too contaminated for playgrounds.) But the law's focus is much broader than toys; manufacturers are worried about items like bicycle spokes and ballpoint pens, which often contain some lead but are not usually seen as a health hazard. Most troubling of all to toymakers is the red tape surrounding the new limits. Under the CPSIA, any children's item, even a hand-knit sweater, will become contraband unless it has undergone expensive testing and has proper papers — it cannot be legally sold, traded, or even given away.

On Friday (January 30), the Consumer Product Safety Commission — the federal agency responsible for enforcing the law — granted makers of children's toys, books, and clothes a welcome reprieve of sorts. From now till next February, the CPSC said, makers can sell their wares without testing. But they still have to meet the new limits. Thus, the announcement is only a stay of execution, dubbed by one small-business blogger "just the epidural, issuing some relief and stamina-gathering before the real pushing begins." While the clock ticks, indie artisans and small businesses will be fighting both Congress and the CPSC to save their livelihoods.

Good guys finish last
Ashland toy importer Rob Wilson considers himself one of the good guys. In a market flooded with soulless plastic Chinese imports, he makes his living selling European cloth puppets and wooden blocks to independent stores like Stellabella and Black Ink. "There's a lot of frustration," says Wilson. "It's a tragic irony that we're the ones bearing the brunt of the law."

1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |   next >
Related: Congress bans kids from libraries?, Obama explained, Camelot: The Next Generation, More more >
  Topics: News Features , toxic, EPA, Environmental Protection Agency,  More more >
| More


Most Popular
ARTICLES BY LISSA HARRIS
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   SURVIVE THE ECONOPOCALYPSE  |  June 11, 2009
    If you're like the more than nine percent of Americans currently unemployed, your "Yes We Can!" has lately lost some of its gusto. You've hit up everyone you know for work, including your mom, your ex, and your ex's ex.
  •   SURVIVING THE ECONOPOCALYPSE  |  June 11, 2009
    If you're like the more than nine percent of Americans currently unemployed, your "Yes We Can!" has lately lost some of its gusto. You've hit up everyone you know for work, including your mom, your ex, and your ex's ex.
  •   CAP AND TRADE EXPLAINED  |  May 06, 2009
    The general idea behind cap and trade is pretty simple: put a tax on pollution, and the market will crank out less of it. But if a pollution tax is a lever, cap and trade is a vast, rickety Rube Goldberg contraption. Ingenious? Yes. Complicated? Fiendishly.
  •   CONGRESS'S WAR ON TOYS  |  February 09, 2009
    Incredible, but true: until this past Friday, America was on a fast track to outlaw grandmothers selling children's sweaters for charity.
  •   CONGRESS BANS KIDS FROM LIBRARIES?  |  January 09, 2009
    Is it possible that Congress has just inadvertently turned millions of children’s books into contraband?

 See all articles by: LISSA HARRIS